Are you anti-Israel? Why?

source : http://redstarcoven.blogspot.com/2007/06/make-israel-history.html

here is my reply :

It is really funny how you attack anyone that is pro Israel, I did not know what you meant on my blog about supernatural.

I love how everyone says occupation this and occupation that.

The palestinians only have a glimmer of a state because Israel is sympathetic to their needs.

Please remind me who was in control of the lands which were CAPTURED fair and square by Israel? West Bank - Jordan, Gaza - Egypt.

Let us say for arguement sake if Israel had not captured those territories do you for one minute think that Egypt or Jordan would allow a palestinian state?

By the way Jordan's King Hussein massacred "palestinian refugees" in the 80's, I think not. While Lebanon is doing the same thing the world turns a blind eye.

People like you Walton are fighting a battle you will eventually loose, because you live in a dream world.

That picture you have of Jews walking around with banners, they are shunned by most sects of judaism and comprise of close to 0.01% of worldwide Jews.

I might understand if you are playing devil's advocate but that can get you into a position that would cause people to think you are an anti-semite.

You say many things in your anti-Israel article that is like a chair with 3 legs very shaky stuff.

I would love to see your evidence that shows Israel targets palestinian civilians, that is quite a harsh assumption, Have you ever been to Israel? if not how can you actually think of giving an objective view? I could assume you are a scared white person who ran away from South Africa as you did not want to live under blacks, but that would be a horrible statement and wrong to give you the benefit of the doubt, is that not true?

I would love to entertain your debate about Israel. But if you do not have hard facts and just using hot air to make the Israelis look bad then I am sorry that is anti-semetic.

Do you realise that freedom of media is only allowed in one country of the middle east - Israel all other countries have full censorship and nothing is allowed to be published by foreign correspondents, especially Syria who incidentally gave a visa to a CNN correspondent the last time was such a long time ago I do not think they even try, and if you do get a visa then Assad's bodyguards are your escorts.

I am under the impression that Israel captured Jerusalem, West Bank, Gaza, Golan Heights fair and square so where is the occupation? It is Israel's property, and in my eyes up to the government and referendums to do with it as they please, is this not right?

The "palestinians" were promised by the arab nations just hold your horses and when we have deatroyed the jews you (palestinians) can have the whole of Israel/palestine. Now answer this question how the hell can the arabs promise them something like that? It is like a homeless person saying to his child don't worry I will get you a playstation 3, absurb. the problem is that the arab nations promised them something and the terrorists are trying to get what they were promised, only one problem they were never promised it by Israel.

It looks like you base all your things on assumptions and that is pretty dumb.

COSATU are bunch of stupid idiots and seeing as you are a trade unionist you fall into the same catergory. Unions always bugger the whole thing up. They forget that imports from Israel amount to about $230 million per annum and exports excluding diamond amount to $290 million per annum, I doubt the palestinians could cover the loss. They forget about the arms they get supplied from Israel, cellphone technology, P4 chips, Win XP, organic insecticides so on and so forth.

By boycotting Israel the times of Vasco da Gama and Captain Cook will be around the corner for South Africa, a good thing you left.

How the hell can you even try comparing Israel to Apartheid? they are 2 different situations, Arabs and women are in the government, Arabs, Jews, Christians are in the army. Israeli-Arabs have the right to vote. Women have the right to vote. 10% of Knesset seats are occupied by Arabs. palestinians are not Israeli citizens and fall under PA control, so to put the blame on Israel is wrong and by the majority of palestinians voting in a terrorist group to be their government, just shows where there loyalty is.

You are very foolish siding with a backstabbing bunch, Israel has bent over backwards for the palestinians and the thanks in return are suicide attacks, home made rockets, road side bombs and the list goes on and on.

Your perception of Zionists are people that want to kill innocent people which is wrong and hurtful, all Zionism is, is patriotism and the love of Zion/Jerusalem that we can one day wake up go to the western wall pray, walk around Jerusalem and not need to look behind our backs in case some idiot wants to kill us just because we are Jews and no other reason.

Those Anti-Zionists as you put it are sleeping with the enemy and if they think for one second that when Ahmadinejad says he wants to destroy Israel that they are safe they must think again, no one gets preferential treatment unless you are one of their kind, I am sure they would convert to Islam at the drop of a hat if it meant their freedom.

I think you need to take a trip to Israel to make sure you understand what you are talking about and then go to the civil war in Gaza and just see if you are giving everyone a fair view about the situation or just spreading gossip.

I must inform you that I do not like the name you gave your link as that is inciting hatred and if I was assuming like you do I would think you would like Israel to not exist, am I right?

Let me guess you are also probably someone who thinks Ahmadinejad wants nuclear power for peaceful means, even if he does what happens if he does not are you willing to put the lives of everyone in the world at risk ?